Paraphrase Practice


Film Review from Civil War Memories: 
"The movie does a very good job of addressing the discrimination faced by the 54th Massachusetts as well as their heroic performance at Battery Wagner in July 1863. One of the themes that the movie captures is the slow progress that Col. Robert G. Shaw experienced in learning to more closely empathize with his men as well as the gradual changes that took place among white Union soldiers as they questioned their own racial outlook in response to the battlefield prowess of black regiments like the 54th... As for problems, well, they abound throughout the movie such as the profile of the regiment, which is presented primarily as a unit of fugitive slaves. Most of the men were free blacks from Massachusetts. Other problems include the time frame for the raising and training of the regiment which began in 1863 rather than 1862 as well as the failure to acknowledge Shaw’s marriage at any point in the movie." 
My Paraphrase: 

Glory correctly portrayed the brave action the men of the 54th Massachusetts took in a Civil Car battle in 1863, despite the injustice thrust upon them. It shows the progress of compassion and understanding the white men of the platoon and Shaw had towards their men as their racists views changed. The movie depicted the men as a group of runaway slaves when in reality they were African American men from the North. The movie is not chronologically correct the upbringing and discipline of the soldiers wasn't until 1863 rather than 1862. The movie also fails to mention Shaw having a wife. 



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Poster Analysis

Image
1. What I know about propaganda is what I learned in World History II last year. I would define it as a method to promote certain views, methods, and invoke a since of pride to contribute. 2. The definition I found was from Merriam-Webster   which defined it as " the spreading of ideas, information, or  rumor  for the purpose of helping or injuring an institution, a cause, or a person or  ideas, facts, or allegations spread deliberately to further one's cause or to damage an opposing cause." 3. SET 4 4.   Enlist on Which side of the Window are You: The first noticeable aspect of the poster is the giant american flag in the background. It is the only part of the poster with a standing out color beside the word "you" in all caps and red. There is a man standing behind a window where it is dark looking out to see dozens of soldiers marching down, rifles in hand, with the flag waving above them in the light. The structure of the poster h...
Read more

Native American Influence

Image
          Wes Stud i  Wesley "Wes" Studi is a Native American (Cherokee) Actor who has expressed his native culture through film. His amazing portals of his characters has changed the modern stereotypes society has placed on Native Americans. His most known performances are his roles in "Dancing with Wolves", "The last of the Mohicans", "Geronimo", "Heat", and "Avatar". Until he was five he only spoke his native Cherokee language. He attended the Chicolo Indian Boarding School in Northern Oklahoma, but unlike many Native American students he never forget his language. After his time in the U.S military he became very politically involved with Native American issues, such as joining the AIM (American Indian Movement) and participated in the Trail of Broken Treaties and Bureau Of Indian Affairs protests. Wes soon moved towards looking for a positive way of change besides through protesting. He then helped publish the Cher...
Read more

Learning History Through Film

Image
Movies can change minds. Although Hollywood cannot get everything historically accurate movies are a great way to experience history through time. Glory and 12 Years a Slave prove that movies can help develop analytical thinking towards real events, circumstances, and attitude by critical watching and researching. Both of these movies were taken from true events that the filmmakers were able to present years of history into a couple of hours. Colonel Shaw The movies were presented in different perspectives to create eye opening experiences of how blacks were treated pre-civil war based on different circumstances. Glory was told from the perspective of a white general leading the 54 th Massachusetts regime. In an interview with director Edward Zwick he was asked why he chose to have the movie told from a white officer’s point of view. He replied,” I think the choice was to try to focus on neither blacks nor whites, but on the regiment. One of the points of the story was to explo...
Read more